[ARCHIVE: This is the pinnacle of any positive output that came from all of my emo-ness (well, so far anyway).]
This is a story, like any story worth telling, about a girl.
Penny was a film enthusiast. Her parents were producers at Paramount so she had grown up in the industry. She wasn't directly involved in the business, so she didn't hob-knob with celebrities all the time. Not that she would. In a business that was primarily about image, Penny was surprisingly genuine. Sure, she was happy and excited to meet celebrities like Chris O'Donnell and Rachel Leigh Cook, but she never presumed that they were her friends.
That's always been one of the things that I've loved about her. She always looked to the inside of a person. That's not to say that she didn't find guys like Ben Affleck attractive. I mean, c'mon, he's Ben Affleck. But she never bought into the posse philosophy of friendship (surrounding oneself with many casual acquaintances). Her companions, although few in number, were fiercely loyal, carefully chosen, and always close at hand. Some people had different associates for different activities. For Penny, there was only one activity: life.
But to Penny, life wasn't tragic or hectic. She wasn't a supernova, trying to live fast and die young. Nor was she lawless, always looking for new and dangerous stunts to pull and deaths to cheat. Life was simply a constant progression towards an uncertain end. Penny didn't want to taste every spice of existence; she just wanted to live while she was alive. There's a certain word for being totally at ease with life. Buddhists call it Enlightenment. Christians call it Salvation. Penny just shrugged her shoulders and called it a given.
Me? I can't claim the same. If Penny was Galadriel from Lord of the Ring, I was Dante from Clerks.
I also grew up with movies. But while Penny got to have lunch breaks with Tom Hanks on set, I had to wait in line like every other theater-goer to see Philadelphia. Movies have always been my chosen form of entertainment. Instead of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and Muppet Babies, I spent my Saturday mornings watching rentals of Ferris Beuller's Day Off and Short Circuit. There were the occasional crossovers, like Transformers: the Movie, but I knew more about Lloyd Bridges than I did about He-Man.
I've always been a consumer of pop culture. In my early years I limited myself to movies, but as I grew older I began to appreciate other media, especially television and music. By the time I was ten, I had abandoned popular music in favor of older performers. I sang the praises of the Beatles and Journey, ignoring New Kids on the Block and MC Hammer. In high school, I parlayed my love and knowledge of music into a part-time job at the music store. This proved to be a mistake, as the inundation of countless inane opinions and customers turned me off. I quit my job and didn't even turn on the radio for a year. I couldn't stand to listen to music for music's sake, but I continued to watch films. In my college years I got a job working in a movie rental place.
The video store and the music store are two very different entities. Music is more easily accessible, so you get to sample all types of preferences, from the narrow to the discerning to the vapid, but all of them very opinionated. In the video store, however, people's tastes are much broader and less defensive. The businessman you lend Chinatown to one night could be back the next week to take out Girls Gone Wild: Spring Break Edition (discreetly, of course). Arguments over film merit were more conversational and less territorial than musical disagreements. People can easily admit that they enjoyed watching Road Trip but concede that it was not a shining example of cinema. Unlike the music store, I enjoyed my job at the rental place. And that's how I found myself working at the video store when Penny walked into my life.
It was a Friday; things usually happened on Fridays, when patrons would come in seeking something to entertain them for the weekend. I tried to work enough hours during the middle of the week so that I could take Friday night off without serious financial repercussions. This particular night, however, was the birthday of a not-so-very close friend, and I needed an excuse to skip out. At the time, it seemed like a viable alternative, dealing with many annoying people for small increments of time, rather than spend an entire evening pretending to be interested in my acquaintance's yammering. By ten that night, though, I was tired, hungry, and out of patience.
So when a dark-haired beauty came up to the counter, I didn't even look up. "Which of these two movies would you recommend?" she asked me, holding up two boxes. Her voice had a lower register, as if the wisdom of ages was hidden inside her slight frame. In any other set of circumstances I would have given her the once over and dismissed her as an Untouchable, one of those women who were beyond the reach of guys like myself, relegated to eye fodder and observed only from afar. But in my place of power (behind the register), and with my wits already strained, I could have given even a young Audrey Hepburn the cold shoulder.
"I don't watch movies," I replied, not looking up from the latest of issue of X-Men.
"You mean to tell me that you haven't heard anything about either of these two movies?" she retorted. To the uninformed bystander, she sounded agitated, ready to launch into a low-customer-appreciation tirade. Later in our relationship, after a lot of experience, I would be able to discern when she was more amused than angry. But I didn't even know her yet, so she still came off as another unruly customer.
"I find it's best to stay out of other people's affairs," was my monotone rejoinder.
Undaunted, she brought her hands down and turned away. Quickly, she faced the counter again, brandishing the two boxes. "Well how about these two?"
"Oh they suck." I didn't bat an eyelash.
"These are the same two movies. You weren't even paying attention."
"And I hope it feels good."
"Of course. Nothing thrills me more than pointing out the shortcomings of others." At this I looked up. Most patrons never picked up the reference (Clerks) and stormed away in a huff. Instead, she had taken my line and turned it on me forcing the ball into my court. The rest of the conversation was a blur of which I remember only that I was smitten by her already. Beautiful, witty, and a Kurosawa fan. She was definitely of a very unique breed. After a lengthy discussion, she didn't rent either Dude, Where's My Car or Rashomon, but The Breakfast Club, and I was left preoccupied for the rest of the night. Not that it mattered; after taking one hour serving that one customer, all the other renters avoided my register.
In a romantic comedy, that particular "scene" would have ended with an encouraging smile from her and a phone number in my hand. But real life works differently. It was a week and a half later that I saw the girl again. It was a Wednesday, and the movie was Almost Famous. I had been a fan of Cameron Crowe's small body of work for quite some time, and although I had hated my record store job, I still had a deep appreciation for music. I was alone that night; my usual cohorts were either socializing in the downtown club scene or covering for me at the video store. Except for James; he was working the ticket booth. Somebody had to let me in for free, right?
So I was in the booth, killing time with J-dogg till my showing. And there she was, standing in line. Two things happen to me when I see a girl that is a potential prospect. One, the initial euphoric feeling, as my heart gets lighter and I smile unintentionally. For me, there's always a second phase, where half a second later my mind takes a complete 180° turn and my fantasies are dashed against the rocks of reality. In this case it was the rather large guy standing next to her in line, chatting her up like there was no tomorrow.
I tried to avert my eyes, to get involved in a conversation with James, anything to keep myself from obsessing over the situation. I had only seen the girl once before; I had no claim over her. So what if she managed to look attractive in a baggy sweatshirt? So what if I didn't remember anything we talked about last time, except a sense of surprise and awe at her refined taste in movies? She was already taken. Story of my life. I was so successful at not looking that my ears started making out their "conversation." I put that in quotes because in no measure could their exchange be considered a discussion. This brute was spewing pick-up lines like the future population of the world depended on it (and they were rather bad ones, too). When I looked up at them, I finally saw that she actually didn't know this guy at all. She was smiling, but her eyes were disinterested. You could tell by looking at them that she desperately wanted to get away.
I can't explain what possessed me at that moment. To this day, the idea of what I did is horrifying and completely out of my character. My history is filled with enough examples of passed opportunities and overlooked chances. But instead, I grabbed two tickets from James and went outside. I approached the two nonchalantly, full with a confidence I couldn't replicate today. Her eyes darted in my direction casually, the way your attention is drawn briefly when someone passes you on the street. You may not know this person, but you look anyway, just to size them up, to fully take in your surroundings. When it was clear that I was walking toward her, she turned her head completely from her admirer.
"Hey hon, didn't see you in line. I got the tickets already. Wanna go in?" I held out the tickets and offered a noncommittal shrug. My heart was racing, even if my body language was casual. The thug's face was frozen in bewilderment, his territory impinged upon by a shorter, thinner, obviously less athletic twerp like myself. Luckily for me, we never had to put it to a test.
She grabbed my arm with both hands and kissed me, standing on tiptoe to reach my lips. It was a move that took the oaf, not to mention myself, by surprise. His face reddening, he mumbled an apology and excused himself to the end of the line where a few of his friends were laughing uproariously (at least, I assume they were his friends by the way he started punching them in the shoulders). Once he was out of earshot, she started giggling, and I soon caught her infectious laughter. "Hi, my name's Penny." And that's how we started dating.
Almost Famous was a great movie. It was wonderfully personal, yet accessible at the same time. True, it was Cameron Crowe's semi-autobiographical story about his youth, but the themes throughout it were familiar to everyone: pubescent alienation, rock star dreams, the "friend zone." And the soundtrack was amazing. It was as if Cameron Crowe had a list of my favorite classic rock songs and simply played them all. Afterwards, I suggested that we go to the local Denny's; we ended up staying there until three in the morning, discussing the merits of new and classic music. As I walked her home, I started to sweat. I really wanted to see Penny again, but she hadn't even breached the subject of getting together again. When we reached the door, I stuttered my way through a request for her phone number. She gave me one of her relaxed, half-smiles, "You don't need my number," then she kissed my cheek and walked inside.
The rest of the week was a waking hell. Over and over I replayed the rejection in my mind. It's not a secret that guys will overanalyze a situation that is not under their control. If things are fine, we don't sweat it. But if the situation is not satisfactory, we think about it way too much. So I kept reliving that night over and over in my head. I was thinking about it in class, at home, I was thinking about it at work. How had it started out so promising and still ended up as nothing in the end? Had she just used me? That was entirely possible; she had needed a way to escape that annoying jock. Maybe she had just chosen the lesser of two evils.
Thinking about it in that way made me sick. I had been a nice guy as far as I could tell. I didn't try to cop a feel, or stick my tongue in her mouth. I hadn't even tried to put my arm around her. And yet, I was still the same in her eyes: another horndog trying to get into her pants. My friends were right. Being a nice guy never got you anything. Or maybe she had expected me to be more forward and transparent. Maybe I had kept my desires so hidden that they were imperceivable, so that I got prematurely thrown into the "friend" category. I felt dumb and rejected. I didn't know why I had even allowed myself to hope. Blarg. I went through the motions of life, not paying attention to what I was doing, so much that I almost missed the Post-It note stuck to the back of a dollar bill the video patron paid with. "Superfresh. 8PM." I looked up and caught the back of Penny's head as she exited. I glanced at the clock; it was 7:45. I talked to Matt, got him to close for me that night, grabbed my coat and left.
As I walked over, my head was a traffic jam, different trains of thought colliding into each other. I decided that I would just have to be straightforward and honest. So when I found Penny in an aisle, I walked up to her and just started talking. "Look, I have a lot of questions right now, and before we do anything else, I think they need to be addressed." She turned and stared at me blankly. "No, just let me finish. I don't know what you think of me, but please believe me when I say that my intentions are not purely physical. I would be lying if I didn't say you were beautiful, but I like more about you than just that. I think we connected with each other, and I think we could continue to connect with each other, and that we should. Because it's so hard to find that these days, y'know? And like, what's going on? I mean, if it was just one date, that's fine, but why the note? And meeting in a supermarket? What's up with that?"
She gave me a look of amusement. "Are you finished?" Dumbstruck, I simply nodded. "Good. What kind of soda do you want?" Numbly, I picked out a six pack of Dr Pepper. As we walked to her place, she apologized for her confusing behavior. "I was afraid. I could tell that you liked me, and I wasn't sure if I wanted to be responsible for someone's happiness. Something similar happened to me with my last relationship, with me caring too much in the end. I thought it better to be rude than to get into something that I would regret."
Silence hung between us, punctuated only by the shuffling of wet leaves under our shoes. "So what changed your mind?"
She turned and smiled at me. "When I realized how much fun I had had."
That night was one of the most surreal nights of my life. We acted as if we had been together for years. Our conversations were filled with playful teasing and intimate moments. We made pasta for dinner that night, working perfectly in tandem. We watched American Beauty, her head resting on my shoulder, my arm around her. Afterwards, we stayed up laughing at horrible reality dating shows until we fell asleep. It was entirely mundane and unexciting. It was perfect.
My relationship with Penny was never dramatic. We didn't do exciting/crazy things, like skydiving, or spend winter break together in a ski lodge. Our most exciting excursion was when we drove to a Billy Joel concert. The concert was in the next town over and we had no cars between the two of us. The local trains were also closed that weekend, so our only option was to borrow a car from one of our friends. This was fine in theory, but what we got was an oversized pickup truck (he was from Texas). We had never driven a vehicle that large before, so getting in and out of parking spaces was an adventure in itself. Added to the fact that we got lost only fifteen minutes into the trip (although we quickly recovered), and we had a lot of stories to giggle over later on.
But it was the typical things that I remember more. Like the one night she came in upset. She was having an anxiety attack about her grades, so to calm her down and take her mind off it, I made frozen pizza and we watched Fantasia 2000. There was nothing memorable or significant about that night, and yet that's the night I remember most vividly. We never tired of each other's company. We would spend entire days just reading on the couch. And it wasn't because we had a lack of things to say; we were just that contented with each other. It was a comfortable silence, like when you lay in bed with somebody before falling asleep. Sure, you could strike up a conversation, but just having them at your side is enough.
So what went wrong?
We had been dating for about six months. In that time, we had only had two, maybe three fights, all of them about very minor things. And the fights themselves were very small, never spilling over five minutes, and never brought up again as ammunition in future conflicts. We were intimate, both physically and emotionally, closer than I had ever been with a human before. So one night, as we lay basking in the afterglow, I let the words slip, "I love you." And then I said, "Forever."
You must remember that I watched a lot of movies. Because of that, my definition of love was, and still is, a bit more classical than that of the common college male of my time. Love wasn't a buzzword I threw out to keep a girl on my booty call list. I used the word sparingly because it represented a feeling that couldn't be duplicated. When I thought of love, I thought of the classic movies, like My Fair Lady and Top Hat; I thought of the original stories of having a "one and only."
The problem with love is that no one seems to understand its value anymore, so they overuse and underrepresent this word that's supposed to describe the most exceptional of emotions. The word love has been cheapened; it doesn't mean love anymore. It's just a step up from really liking something. So I try to use it rarely, to preserve what little significance it has. So when I said "I love you," I didn't mean it in a "Wow, this Burger King Whopper, with its flame broiled patty, sesame seed bun, and tasty slice of American cheese is an oral sensory overload of really really really really ridiculously great goodness," way. I meant it in a "Every moment I spend with you is better than all my other days combined, and I want to spend the rest of my life with you" way. And I meant it. I was long past the stage of uncertainty, so my feelings were not only genuine but also deep-rooted. I loved Penny, and so I told her.
One week later, she dumped me.
It was a Friday. I had gone to morning classes, and decided that instead of sitting through more class during the afternoon, I would take Penny out for lunch, and then we would waste the rest of the day in bed. I went back to my place to drop off my books, stopping to chat with my roommate for a bit. As we were talking, Penny came in, her face calm and searching. Most people would have thought she was just preoccupied. But I knew her well enough to recognize the signs of worry; the twitching of her mouth as she subvocalized her thoughts, the habitual way she tugged on the skin at the base of her neck, the slight uncertainty in her step as she walked.
I tried to ask her what was wrong. She only asked for my help in fixing her fire alarm. I didn't want to push anything so I went along with it. I figured she would tell me when she was ready. We walked back to her place, where I immediately recognized the problem. The battery in the alarm had run low, so it was emitting a high-pitched beep every thirty seconds. A long enough time to give the illusion of silence, but frequent enough to drive normal people crazy.
As I grabbed a chair and went to work, she sat down on "The Ottoman," her blue floral print footstool. She had picked it up at a trendy store in an effort to diversify the furniture of her place. Her friends, including me, had teased her incessantly about it, but in the end we had all grown attached to it. I popped the cover off the alarm, the blinking red LED light flashing in my eyes. Unfortunately, without a replacement nine volt battery, the only thing I could do for the moment was to take the thing down. The entire time I had been chattering away, trying to cheer her up. By the time I had finished, she was still sitting on the ottoman, watching me attentively but not interacting actively. I asked her again what was wrong, and she replied, "It doesn't feel right." There was no context to the sentence. And yet, by the subtle clues, the shift in her eyes, the way she was pulling at her hair, I instinctively knew what she was talking about.
I argued with her for a few futile hours, gaining no ground. It seems that with my revelation, I had placed a burden of guilt on her. Before, it was just about fun. Now, it was about emotion, something she couldn't handle or reciprocate. "Do you know how it feels to be responsible for someone's happiness?" I thought about my previous girlfriend, but kept my mouth shut. "It's like this, this, this enormous pressure. Everything I do, I second-guess. I, I can't deal with thought that I might do something that makes you sad. It's too big for me, I can't do it, not right now."
I tried to convince her that I didn't care, that it wasn't important to me that she "return" my feelings as long as I could make her happy. But she remained obstinate. "You say you don't care, but every time you do something nice for me, it makes me feel even guiltier. I can't make you feel as good as you make me feel. I, I don't deserve this kind of treatment." It's strange how in any other context, that would have meant something entirely different. "Look, it's just better to cut it now, before it someone gets hurt." Too late for that, isn't it? I fell back on my last option and tried to get her to let the relationship keep going until she could return my feelings. But she called my bluff, pointing out (quite truthfully in retrospect) that despite my best efforts I would grow to resent her for not feeling the same way. As I walked out the door into the rain in my black trench coat, I remember thinking that John Cusack had nothing on me.
For months I was miserable. Every lousy pop song spoke to me; every romantic comedy I passed could stop me in my tracks; I didn't even leave my room for the first few days, sustaining myself on Gatorade and Cup o' Noodles. I lost myself in movie binges, watching my DVDs over and over again, trying to find the old uplifting feelings of hope I used to feel. Nothing. The only movies that I could take anything from were Fight Club and The Killer. I had hit my bottom. It wasn't a self-mutilation or tempting-death-thing like Tyler Durden explained it, but the sudden loss of direction was brutal but one as idealistic as me. I don't remember when I got better. One day I just woke up, took a shower, and continued on. I was far from okay, but I was moving about.
We don't talk anymore. We can't. A year later she transferred. I didn't get her new address or phone number, but I didn't want them. Like a shadow across my life, she came in and left just as quickly. It's probably better this way, though, that it's a story with an exact start and beginning, a well defined subquest of life. But not a day goes by that I don't think about her. It's not as bad anymore, not a heavy weight that sits in the middle of my chest. Now it's just like a memory of the past, one that I look upon as a one of the proverbial "better times." I can laugh and joke again, even goad my friends into relationships themselves (James is currently pursuing his own conquest). But Penny is never discussed, never referenced, never mentioned.
Sometimes it's hard to believe she even existed. She was only the best I ever had, but I don't have a picture, a keepsake, a forgotten pair of underwear. And yet I still have a Valentine's bear, still in its plastic bag, next to a copy of Singles, still waiting for an owner. But really, that's what I got out of love. It's not the gifts I gave her or even the kisses we shared that are important. Love isn't the deeper connection between two people. It's the potential for that connection. And finally understanding all this, I'm trapped by my own words. I meant what I said. And even though I'll never see her again, I'll always love her. The movies taught me, but Penny gave me the experience, that love is, and should be, something that is meaningful and nigh-unchangeable. I'm sorry Penny, wherever you are.
Read More......